40 Comments
User's avatar
Ely's avatar

I saw Above And Beyond when it first came out. I was a two-year-old when the Egyptian Air Force bombed Tel-Aviv. Perhaps I wouldn’t be alive today if it wasn’t for men like Lou Lenart. What a man!

Expand full comment
Jeff Sniderman's avatar

Thanks so much for brightening our day amidst all of the difficult news coming from Gaza and the world's hostile response. It helps to remember that we have overcome greater challenges in our past.

Expand full comment
Chris DeMuth Jr's avatar

Orde Wingate is one of my heroes. I've read every book about him but now really hope that movie gets made someday.

Expand full comment
Landscape Artist's avatar

Amazing empowering story about a man with those same qualities. Thank you, Michael, for writing about and sharing Lou’s story. My grandmother Rosalie’s second husband Harold was Hungarian. In my youth, she told me to Never marry a Hungarian. This story, while reminding us of true heroism and ingenuity, seems to support Rosie’s belief.

Expand full comment
Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

Here's Lou being interviewed

https://youtu.be/odsrPRJwmPw?si=zCJW-sEkuCpYXUKV

Terrific article!

Leonard Slater wrote the Pledge regarding these heroes

Expand full comment
Jay Kaplan's avatar

Thank you for this link. I had no idea this video existed.

I first learned much of this story from Nancy Spielberg's "Above and Beyond". Many of the people in this video are featured in Nancy's film. And I was lucky enough to see the Israel premier of "Above and Beyond' in Jerusalem. Lou was introduced in the audience and I think the audience would still be applauding and cheering until today had Nancy had not asked us to stop.

Thanks again for your post.

Expand full comment
Kafr Dhimmi's avatar

Michael I think daily of Jabotinsky and also Brigadier Wingate and Trumpledor you made me cry. Thank you. These are scary times.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

What A Mensch!

"“I came to fight the Arabs, not kill Jews.”"

THUMBS UP!!!

Expand full comment
Adam's avatar

The story of Orde Wingate would make a fantastic movie.

Especially relevant in our time. An extraordinary hero.

We must get your screenplay made!

May it be so...

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

That is The Forgotten Battle. And you are right, it would. The problem is Hollywood would Screw It Up, as they so often do.

Expand full comment
Peter Jones's avatar

The could call it...

Most got malaria!

Expand full comment
Laura Hoffman's avatar

You are such a good writer Michael. I loved reading your inspiring, moving story about Lou. Toda.

Expand full comment
Jeff Jacoby's avatar

Legend! What a remarkable man, about whom I had never previously heard. He too would make a great subject for a film. Many thanks for sharing his story, Michael.

(P.S. The adjective in the headline should be "tenebrous," not "tenebris," no?)

Expand full comment
Hannah Komy's avatar

I also mentioned that point in my comment.

Expand full comment
Richard's avatar

I'm going to watch the movie again right now.

Expand full comment
Walter Sobchak, Esq.'s avatar

Michael: thank you very much for a wonderful story about a true Jewish hero.

If you, or anyone in your family, has not watched "Above and Beyond" by Nancy Spielberg (Steven's sister), do so as soon as possible. If is available on numerous streaming services. A quick Google search will show you which ones.

Expand full comment
Peter Lerner's avatar

Michael, I feel impelled to interrupt this comment flow on Lou Lenart to urge you to view the 1 1/2 hour podcast interview, which I just saw on YouTube, of Robert F Kennedy defending Israel's conduct of the Gaza War. The interviewer/debate opponent was Dave Smith, whose excellence as a debater was recently demonstrated in his interview/podcast with Chris Cuomo, in that case talking about the Government's handling of Covid. I think it fair to say that Smith brilliantly demolished Cuomo, but was just as brilliantly taken down by RFK -- whose "performance" should get the widest possible distribution. That is where you come in, possibly. How to do that? PSL

Expand full comment
Shelah Horvitz's avatar

Just wow. Such a thrilling story and it filled in some questions I had about how Israel was able to fight as soon as it got independence. You are right, this needs to be a film. Hope someday it gets the backing.

Expand full comment
Not so young anymore.'s avatar

Amazing hero of the Jewish state and the Jewish people!

Expand full comment
David Harold Chester's avatar

That's a truly great story of one of our hero's. Thanks for letting us learn about Lou. I will try to find more about him. As a one-time trainee pilot who failed to qualify, I know how it feels to pilot and fly in an unfamiliar aircraft, and to go to war in one must have taken great courage!

Expand full comment